Sisyphus Shrugged - Round up the usual suspects.
Lasciate ogni speranza and put your feet up.
jmhm
[info]jmhm
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Round up the usual suspects.
The latest two-minute hate making the rounds has to do with Kos, at the Daily Kos.

The short story is: Kos said that he didn't mourn the deaths of mercenaries, and a storm blew up.

This was his explanation:
There's been much ado about my indifference to the Mercenary deaths in Falluja a couple days ago. I wrote in some diary comments somewhere that "I felt nothing" and "screw them".

My language was harsh, and, in reality, not true. Fact is, I did feel something. That's why I was so angry.

I was angry that five soldiers -- the real heroes in my mind -- were killed the same day and got far lower billing in the newscasts. I was angry that 51 American soldiers paid the ultimate price for Bush's folly in Iraq in March alone. I was angry that these mercenaries make more in a day than our brave men and women in uniform make in an entire month. I was angry that the US is funding private armies, paying them $30,000 per soldier, per month, while the Bush administration tries to cut our soldiers' hazard pay. I was angry that these mercenaries would leave their wives and children behind to enter a war zone on their own violition.

So I struck back.

Unlike the vast majority of people in this country, I actually grew up in a war zone. I witnessed communist guerillas execute students accused of being government collaborators. I was 8 years old, and I remember stepping over a dead body, warm blood flowing from a fresh wound. Dodging bullets while at market. I lived in the midsts of hate the likes of which most of you will never understand (Clinton and Bush hatred is nothing compared to that generated when people kill each other for politics or race or nationality). There's no way I could ever describe the ways this experience colors my worldview.

Back to Iraq, our men and women in uniform are there under orders, trying to make the best of an impossible situation. The war is not their fault, and I will always defend their honor and bravery to the end of my days. But the mercenary is a whole different deal. They willingly enter a war zone, and do so because of the paycheck. They're not there for humanitarian reasons (I doubt they'd donate half their paycheck to the Red Cross or whatever). They're there because the money is DAMN good. They answer to no one except their CEO. They are dangerous, hence international efforts (however fruitless they may be) to ban their use.

So not only was I wrong to say I felt nothing over their deaths, I was lying. I felt way too much. Nobody deserves to die. But in the greater scheme of things, there are a lot of greater tragedies going on in Iraq (51 last month, plus countless civilians and Iraqi police). That those tragedies are essentially ignored these days is, ultimately, the greatest tragedy of all.

Needless to say, this and subsequent apologies were not taken by the keyboard warriors who are so incensed by Kos' comments.

The dead mercenaries were americans, and for the deaths of americans we must mourn.

Leading the pack, theres lgf.

Bit of a policy switch on their part. Here we find Mr. Johnson and his brigade of good taste commandos "dancing on the grave" of american activist Rachel Corrie, who apparently lost her right to not be verbally desecrated after death in perpetuity when she chose to side with the palestinian cause in Israel. Ms. Corrie was run down by a bulldozer while attempting to block the destruction of a palestinian house.

Of the death of "St Pancake," Mr. Johnson said this:
In other words, she arrogantly believed her US citizenship and white skin conferred invulnerability upon her saintly corpus?

Presumably that reality check is some comfort to the families of the dead contractors.

A year later, the crowd at lgf gave their Idiotarian of the Year award to the late Ms. Corrie, as approvingly covered by James Taranto of the Wall Street Journal, which likewise calls for only the strictest adherence to the nil nisi bonum rule for american deaths:
Little Green Footballs has given out its second annual Robert Fisk Award for Idiotarian of the Year. This year's winner: Rachel Corrie, the terror advocate who died in a bulldozer accident last March. Corrie picked up 28.8% of the vote in the 10-candidate finals, edging out Michael Moore (26.7%), who also finished second (behind Jimmy Carter) in 2002. Moore, who we hear dedicated his most recent "book" to Corrie, is the Susan Lucci of idiotarians. As one LGF commenter writes, "Michael Moore has to be crushed he didn't win."

Get it? Crushed? Like, under a bulldozer?

I'd give credit to the wag in question, but it was an old joke. One of the first lgf commenters to address the death of this american suggested that someone run a bulldozer over Mr. Moore.

And there was much rejoicing.

Of course, in the good taste sweepstakes, you cant get much more appropriate than the Anti Idiotarian Rottweiler, also deeply offended by Kos comments, who with his readers sent pizzas (get it? Pizza? Like someone looks like after a bulldozer runs over them?) to the IDF in case anyone was peckish after the strenuous work of running Ms. Corrie over with a bulldozer.

Professor Reynolds, himself an advocate of harsh remedies against enemies of the state, does not himself feel the need to apologize for the Rottweiler and has not delinked to lgf. lgf, in turn, has not delinked from the Rottweiler, despite the fact that Ms. Corries death was not the only time that personage has stepped into the arena to celebrate the death of an american. The difference is, the other time, he tried to arrange for one.

The selftitled Rottweiler, a gentleman with strong opinions about his own masculinity which he is not loath to share with the gentlemen who make up his audience, Took exception to a Kucinich flash ad criticizing the war, suggested that the blogger who produced the ad be killed from behind and his face taken off with a belt sander, and provided a helpful map to that bloggers house house (with a star showing the location) from nearby Fort Dix labelled Road Trip.

Amusingly, the death threat was sparked by the Rottweiler taking offense that Kucinich "used our war dead to push his agenda."

Thank god irony is dead. It would never survive this.

I think the last word here should go to prominent bloghawk Andrew Sullivan, who had this to say about americans going overseas to fight and die:
I'm sorry but I pay for those soldiers to fight in a volunteer army. They are servants of people like me who will never fight. Yes, servants of civil masters. And they will do what they are told by people who would never go to war. That's called a democracy.

Chirp.

Kos did not celebrate the deaths of americans. If you make excuses for this war, you did.
Comments
From: [info]dublingal_ny Date: April 4th, 2004 02:48 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
Chrisht a'mighty you deserve some sort of reward for wading through the sites you're linking here. Vile vile vile vile vile.
aberranteyes From: [info]aberranteyes Date: April 4th, 2004 02:55 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)

Wheel of Morality, turn, turn, turn...

...tell us the lesson that we should learn.

*DING*

"Moral #3- People who live in glass houses... Should get dressed with the lights off."
temima From: [info]temima Date: April 4th, 2004 03:21 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
The pizza thing was before Corrie's death. Otherwise, these guys at Little Green Madrassahs are asshats.
jmhm From: [info]jmhm Date: April 4th, 2004 03:48 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
hmmm? thought the link I saw was from after.

guess it was too good a joke not to recycle.
supergee From: [info]supergee Date: April 4th, 2004 04:24 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
Political correctness must be enforced! Any insensitive remarks must be stamped out immediately lest they hurt someone's feelings! (Oops, sorry, wrong side.)
braincake From: [info]braincake Date: April 4th, 2004 06:47 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
I've said it before, the Malboge will be overflowing with armchair generals when they finally kick off. I didn't agree with Kos' original post, but he's bloody well explained his point by now. He deserves better than to be hit like that.

I even take a bit of umbrage at Kerry's staff. I'm disappointed that his staff has pulled ads, though it's not a big surprise with this election being so close and the amount of paranoia that has to have been built up by now on the GOP Media Circus and its penchant for "finding" scandals to talk to themselves about.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 4th, 2004 07:12 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)

kos

More sense. Good work. But can you work up one of these for Tacitus? I can't bear to read him, but his comments are popping up everywhere and pissing me off.
strixnebulosa From: [info]strixnebulosa Date: April 4th, 2004 10:23 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
As a random question from a relative blog-newbie, what's the origin of "chirp"?
jmhm From: [info]jmhm Date: April 4th, 2004 11:50 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
it suggests that while you wait for the response that seems to be called for, all you hear is crickets chirping.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 4th, 2004 10:33 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)
People need to start thinking for themselves. I do not mourn for Americans just because they are Americans. I mourn for everyone of the world equally. Americans have no more claim on this earth than any other nationality. I do not mourn the death of hired killers, American or not. If you do, I pity you.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 5th, 2004 08:39 am (UTC) (linkie thing)
Let's not forget Stephen den Beste (http://www.denbeste.nu/cd_log_entries/2002/09/Whoisourenemy.shtml) who "forthrightly caled for cultural genocide" or Misha who was prepared to celebrate the bombing of the UN comlex by popping the champaign until he learned that the bombing was in Baghdad instead of New York.

Dwight
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 5th, 2004 11:22 am (UTC) (linkie thing)

It depends on what you are fighting for.

I didn't particularly like how some people played the Rachel Corrie death. It was tragic and unfortunate. But people on both sides took it too far. You listed out the extreme responses on the right. The left literally made her a martyr and a symbol for Jew hatred. She was fighting to support murderers and thugs. Specifically at the accident she was fighting to protect houses that covered tunnels used to move arms across the Egyptian border to kill Israelis. She wasn't an evil person and was most likely just misguided, but she was no hero either. That said she died for a cause she believed in and some respect goes to that.

Kos on the other hand said some things that he should have apologized for. The people he said he felt nothing for were doing something good. They weren't fighting for the death or suppression of a group of people. They were protecting food convoys. The only reason you people can show this level of ambivilance is because you hate the president that made this happen.

People that support this war don't want people to get killed, which is more than you can say for many of the people around the world that opposed it. But we who support the war, and the soldiers in combat, believe there are things worth fighting for and risking your life for. Sometimes they die for this belief and none of us like it. But the world isn't a fantasy realm where Saddam could have been removed peacefully, and it is ridiculous to think so. What we have accomplished in Iraq is incredible and the vast majority of Iraqi's appreciate it greatly. The military personal AND civilians over there deserve to be treated honorably whether you like President Bush or not.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 5th, 2004 11:38 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)

Re: It depends on what you are fighting for.

WTF? People who opposed the war in Iraq want people to get killed? Holy shit, that is the most bizarre thing I have read today, and I have read many, many things, my friend. I've been to Instastupid, LGF, Las Vegas and a World's Fair in my time. Wow.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 6th, 2004 10:36 am (UTC) (linkie thing)

Re: It depends on what you are fighting for.

let me get this straight:

Soldiers of Fortune, hired guns, mercenaries risking their lives for $30K/month are somehow equivalent to Rachel Corrie, a PEACE activist?

These same SoFs, who are risking their lives for $30K/month in a war zone, are more worthy of the intense media attention they received for their gruesome deaths than the young military grunts, risking their lives for a belief in their country, killed the same day in far-off Bagdahd?

These SoFs were guarding food convoys for MONEY! They are not humanitarians or some militarized version of Doctors without Borders! These are soldiers of fortune doing this job because they want to make good money and have the opportunity to do so because of this unfortunate, disgusting war.

I guess I just don't "get" why I'm supposed to be weeping at the graves of these men? Yes, it's terrible they were mutilated, but they knew exactly what they were doing when they CHOSE to take those jobs. And by seeking to make money off this tragic war they're enabling this mess to continue.

On the other hand our soldiers, ignored by Bush since the beginning and suffering cutbacks in hazard pay while they continue to wait for the body armor that was promised to them, have no choice but to fight and risk their lives there.

Where is the equivalent outrage from your side over the 615+ lives lost in gruesome ways? Over the cancellation of rotation out of that hell hole for 24,000 soldiers who've spent the last year of their lives there?

crickets crickets
From: [info]platosearwax Date: April 5th, 2004 11:39 pm (UTC) (linkie thing)

Oh my

That was awesome. I've spent way too much time perusing LGF and the Rottweiller. You pretty much nailed them.

Really, really nice work.
ahhhs. -- hmmm?
profile
Sisyphus Shrugged
User: [info]jmhm
Name: Sisyphus Shrugged
links
tags